VroniPlag Wiki Scorecard - Part II

This is the second part of the VroniPlag Wiki scorecard, without the barcodes, as they are now generated automatically when you visit the page, and are thus always up to date there.

Thesis,
Link
Name,
University
Documentation
public
Current
status
Ld Lukas Danckert,
University of Kiel
2012-12-22
Still pending
Ht
Hakan Tastan (1)
University of Gießen
2012-12-27 In June 2013 decision: not plagiarism
Ab
Andrea Baust,
University of Heidelberg
2013-01-01
Still pending
Cmg
Carmen Marie Gottwald, University of Würzburg 2013-01-02 Still pending
Tj
Thiemo-Marcell Jeck,
University of Frankfurt/M
2013-02-04 Doctorate rescinded after 6 weeks
Rm
Ronald Moeder,
University of Innsbruck, Austria
2013-02-19 Still pending
Ees
Eike Eric Scheller,
Charité Berlin (Habilitation)
2013-03-15 Still pending
Jkr
Jakob Kreidl,
Universität der Bundeswehr, München
2013-03-21
After 9 months the university rescinded the doctorate
Hta
Hakan Tastan (2)
University of Gießen
2013-03-25
In June 2013 decision: not plagiarism
Ks
Katja Stammen,
University of Bielefeld
2013-04-26 As of September 2014, doctorate rescinded after 17 months
Df
Doris Fiala,
ETH Zürich (MAS)
2013-05-10
Master rescinded after 8 weeks
Uo
Ulrike Oppelt,
Free University Berlin
2013-07-04
Still pending
Ssh Shahram Sheikhzadeh,
RWTH Aachen
2013-08-31 Still pending
Wy
Weizhong Yi,
Humboldt University, Berlin
2013-09-12 Still pending
Mah Muwafaq Abu-Hammoud,
RWTH Aachen
2013-09-14 Still pending
Maa Mohamed Al Awabdeh,
HU Berlin
2013-09-14 Still pending
Mkl
Martin Klever,
RWTH Aachen
2013-09-27 Still pending
Asc
Andrea Schöndube,
HU Berlin
2013-09-27 Still pending
Tmu
Timur Mukazhanov,
University of Freiburg/Br.
2013-10-02 Still pending
Gjb
Gerardo J. Briceño,
University of Freiburg/Br.
2013-10-05 Still pending
Fws
Frank-Walter Steinmeier,
University of Gießen
2013-10-11 After six weeks the university decides: not scientific misconduct
Sm Solaiman Mufti,
University of Gießen
2013-11-03 Still pending
Db Derya Biyikli,
University of Hamburg
2013-12-02 Still pending
Hk Hüdayi Korkusuz,
University of Gießen
2013-12-02 Still pending
Stf Stephan Fahnemann,
University of Würzburg
2014-01-06 Still pending
Ahe
Abedelhakeem Helassa,
University of Münster
2014-02-03 Still pending
  Zs
Zhongsheng Sun,
University of Kiel
2014-02-03 Still pending
  Jm
Jennifer L. Moore,
National University of Ireland, Maynooth
2014-02-09 Still pending
Arc Ana Catarina Ribeiro Carrão, FU Berlin 2014-02-28 Still pending

I have been writing to the universities for many months now in order to hear what has happened. Either I am ignored, or told that it's a secret, or informed that the case is still pending.

Update 2013-11-06:  Gießen does not see plagiarism in Steinmeier's thesis, and also inform me that both of the doctorates of Ht are still intact, although the committee did find the plagiarized portions to be "problematic". It was also announced that the University of Bochum has decided not to proceed with an investigation of the thesis of Norbert Lammert, they only see handwerkliche Mängel, technical weaknesses.
Update 2013-12-27: The two named cases from December were added to the list, still no news on many of the other cases except Jakob Kreidl, his doctorate was rescinded after 9 months deliberation. I suppose a round of emails asking the universities if they are still working on the cases is in order for January 2.
Update 2014-09-03: Arc was case #65 on VroniPlag Wiki. In the past six months,  53 additional cases have been published on the page, and I am not able to keep up here. In particular, a cluster of cases in medicine in Münster and the Charité, Berlin with 23 and to date 20 additional cases gives me no chance to keep up, so I won't be continuing the scorecard, save for updates should there be any on any of the cases.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Please note that I moderate comments. Any comments that I consider unscientific will not be published.